person looking at a city view from above
Shutterstock

There’s a ton a fantastic info (a lot right here on The Muse!) about how to rock a job interview and leave your prospective employer slack-jawed with amazement—applauding and hurling a job offer across the table while dollar bills, confetti, and balloons rain down from a trapdoor in the ceiling.

“You got the job!” he proclaims as Katy Perry’s “Roar” blasts through a set of speakers, tucked away in the hidden trapdoor compartment. (Lots of trapdoors in today’s modern conference rooms. Everyone knows that.)

For example, this article. And this one. Plus this.

All terrific advice. That is, assuming you’ve actually been called in.

But, what if no matter how hard you try, nobody is calling or emailing to invite you to come by for an interview? And you can’t figure out why?

This piece is for you.

Here are eight reasons why you’re not catching the hiring manager’s attention—and what to do about it.


1. Your Resume Is Boring

You’ve heard this a million times before, but it’s true. If you’re going after a top company—think: Google, which receives over 2 million job applications per year—you’re entering some pretty stiff competition. Your resume has got to stand out.

But this doesn’t mean adding tons of swirly fonts or using neon green paper. One simple tweak that makes a huge difference is changing responsibility-focused descriptions (“Responsible for rewriting the text on the breakfast menu”) to quantifiable, achievement-focused descriptions (“Revamped breakfast menu, increased sales by 80%). Boom. Your resume: now 80% more awesome.

A few other simple changes can be found in this article.

2. Your Cover Letter’s Too General

If you’ve got one cover letter template that you are blasting out to dozens of potential employers—and the only phrasing you’re changing is the name that follows the word “Dear”—that’s a problem. The person reading your cover letter will be able to tell that this is a “generic” letter without much heart and soul.

Instead, you’re going to have to bite the bullet and actually customize each letter. That means spelling out why you’re qualified for this specific position, as well as why you’re excited to work for this specific company. (Here’s some good advice to follow.)


3. You’ve Been Contacting the Wrong Person

This is such a rookie mistake, but it’s more common than you might think. Triple-check to make sure you’ve been emailing your resume and cover letter to the appropriate person. If you’re not sure who that person is, you have two options.

Option one: Go to LinkedIn and search for the person most likely to be the position’s hiring manager. That could be someone in the department you’re applying to, or the company’s talent recruiter. Or, option two: Contact someone in the HR department and ask who you should be submitting your materials to. It’s as easy as sending a LinkedIn message that says:

“I’m applying to the Marketing Manager position and really excited about the opportunity. I wanted to double check that I’m sending my materials to the right place. Can you let me know the best email for the hiring manager? Thank you for your time.”


4. You Didn’t Tell a Good Story

The number one way to captivate someone’s attention is to tell an intriguing story. This isn’t hokey, old-timey wisdom. It’s science! The human mind is wired to remember details from stories much more vividly than dry, boring facts.

Try to weave one consistent “story” into your resume, cover letter, portfolio, professional website, social media profiles, or whatever your potential employer uses to scope candidates out.

For example, here’s a hypothetical example from a career-changer’s LinkedIn.

“Former middle school teacher turned marketing specialist. Ask me about how to grip your audience’s attention, even if they’re highly distracted and raging with hormones.”

That’s not only attention-grabbing, but it’s also informative.


5. You Ramble Like Crazy

In a crowded job-hunting space where employers are skimming hundreds of applications, being overly wordy is just not going to fly. No one has time to figure out what you’re trying to say—so you need to spell it out. Force yourself to trim your cover letter and resume down to one page. Remember: You can cut out anything that’s irrelevant to this specific position.


6. You’re Underqualified

If you use phrases like, “This job would be a huge, tremendous honor for me” or “While I may not have the required experience,” it makes you seem like a newbie without many skills to offer. Switch to a more neutral tone, while still retaining your positivity and enthusiasm. For example, “I’m excited to apply...” is a better way to show you’re pumped about this position.


7. You’re Overqualified

Getting in front of a hiring manager when you’re clearly overqualified for the job requires some finesse. Whether you’ve been a perpetual intern, a lay-off casualty, or a career changer, the most important thing is to confront the issue head on. Lay the foundation in your cover letter, articulating the reasons for your career switch or why you’re willing to take a job that appears beneath you.

Remain positive and excited about your situation, while making sure to highlight all the ways your experience will benefit the company. Last, but not least, be sure to emphasize why you want to work at this particular company. Remember that the last thing a hiring manager wants to feel is that this is a temporary gig for you and that you’ll jump ship at the first opportunity.


8. You Sound Desperate

It’s been proven by science: Your brain is wired to crave things that you can’t have. Annoying but true! That’s why if you seem in high demand—or if you already have a great job—employers often seem more eager to hire you. When you sound desperate? Not so much.

Even if you’re feeling a bit desperate, do your best to convey a firm, confident tone. (This cover letter-writing mind trick can help you to tap into that confident place, even if it seems like a big stretch.)


Good luck out there and try to stay positive. It may seem like an unbelievable amount of effort just to land a good job—and sometimes, it is—but at the end of the day, nothing compares to the joy of having a job that you really, genuinely love. Big effort to get there? Sometimes. Totally worth it? Always.