Not that long ago, I was flying home from a speaking engagement next to a woman who was diligently preparing what appeared to be a financial analysis. As the plane was rolling down the runway, she snapped her computer shut and looked over to smile at me.
“Looming deadline?” I asked.
She shook her head and said, “There’s always a deadline.”
We chatted amiably for a few minutes before I began asking the kind of questions I always ask of women on the road. What they do for a living, whether they enjoy their work, and when they last asked for a raise.
“I’m pregnant,” she said, “so I didn’t ask for a raise this year. I won’t even be getting a bonus because I’m taking the last two months of the year off.”
I suggested that she ought to be getting 80% of her bonus since she will have worked 80% of the year, at which point she said she’d be lowering her ambitions for quite some time what with the baby and all. She thought she wouldn’t be able to develop business the way her colleagues were. She was so certain of this that she’d given a younger male colleague the credit for business she’d developed that year—a two million dollar account.
I wish this story were uncommon. Unfortunately, I’ve talked to hundreds of high performers who accept far less than they are due for a myriad of reasons, some because they’re planning on starting a family soon and others because they took one or two years off when they first had children. Others don’t seek a raise or counter a low-ball first compensation offer because they’re afraid the offer will be withdrawn or that they’ll be punished in some other way simply because they ask to be paid their true market value.
To encourage women like my accidental traveling companion to ask for the compensation to which they’re entitled, I give you eight facts that should scare you into asking for a raise.
1. Whatever You’re Earning in Your 40s Is the Most You’ll Likely Ever Earn
According to a study conducted by Payscale.com, college-educated men’s earnings peak at 48, while women’s stall at 39, nearly 10 years earlier. (No wonder there’s a staggering pay gap at the top of the pay scale!). So, if you’re thinking that you’ll negotiate “next time,” when you’re that much more experienced, don’t put it off any longer. You don’t have that much time.
2. Repaying Your Student Loans Will Probably Take a While
The standard repayment plan for federal student loans puts borrowers on a 10-year track to pay off their debt, but research has shown average bachelor's degree holders take 21 years to pay off their loans. That means, even if you’re single and living with roommates now, you’ll still be paying these off at the same time you’re saving the down payment for a house, socking money away for your children’s education, and (ideally) putting additional sums into your 401K or IRA to start preparing for retirement.
3. If You Want to Send Your (Eventual) Kid to College, You Need to Save $425 Every Month
According to the “World’s Simplest College Cost Calculator,” if you plan on sending your kid to a public college for four years, you need to start saving at least $425 a month from the day she’s born to the moment you drop her off at her new home on campus. And that’s according to a March 2016 figure. If your child isn’t even a figment in your imagination yet, that number’s likely to go up even more.
4. Single Motherhood for College-Educated Women Over 35 Is Increasing
Although divorce among married college graduates has been in decline for sometime, so has marriage. Recently, only one group of unmarried women have seen their birthrates increase—those 35 and over. Whether those women were divorced before their first (or second!) child or were never married, they will likely be the sole wage earners for most or all of their children’s lives.
5. The Wage Gap Will Likely Widen as Millennial Women Age
There’s both good and bad news for women between the ages of 25 to 34. A 2015 Pew Research survey shows their hourly earnings were 93% of their male peers. Whether women will be able to keep pace, however, may depend largely on them. Previous generations of women have fallen behind their male counterparts as they have aged and dealt with the responsibilities of parenthood and family.
6. Women Slide Into Poverty During Their Retirement Years
Women who are over 65 today are nearly twice as likely to live below the poverty line. As CNN recently reported, women over 65 are living on an income of $16,000 per year while their male counterparts have $11,000 more to spend on necessities every year. And at that annual income, it’s all necessities. This is unsurprising for today’s female retirees given the size of the pay gap during their lifetimes, but absent constant vigilance, the smaller Millennial pay gap can easily increase over time. If you earn less now, reach your peak earnings at 39, and live 20 to 30 years post-retirement, much of your “golden years” will be spent simply struggling to survive.
7. You’re Leaving Half a Million Dollars on the Table
A couple of researchers recently cautioned job seekers not to leave money on the table. In Who Asks and Who Receives in Salary Negotiation they found that employees who negotiated their compensation increased their annual pay an average of $5,000. They warned that if a 25-year-old who fails to negotiate a starting salary of $55,000 instead of the $50,000 on the table, over a 40-year career, that individual will lose more than half a million dollars. That’s $634,000 to be exact.
8. There’s Little to No Risk in Asking
This has likely been eye-opening enough for you, so let’s end with a not-so-scary fact: The VP of Human Resources for CareerBuilder says that nearly half of all employers surveyed said they had more money than initially offered, but 49% of all job candidates—male and female—simply didn’t ask for it. And there goes your last excuse for not asking for more.
Back to the airplane where my seatmate was planning for a financially circumscribed future despite despite all the talk about “leaning in” and “negotiating your true value.” As our conversation deepened, she acknowledged that she was the primary breadwinner in her family and, yes, she did want to send her children to good colleges. She herself had earned her MBA from Wharton and her BA from Stanford. She still had student debts to pay, as did her husband.
And baby makes three.
Despite my new acquaintance’s feared inability to develop business, she’d already brought a two million dollar account into her firm with so little apparent effort that she’d freely given the credit for that accomplishment to someone else.
I didn’t mince words: “You know, you might just as well have handed your colleague a couple of hundred thousand dollars out of your savings account.”
“I know,” she replied ruefully. “My sister’s a lawyer and she’s always urging me to ask for more.”
Bottom line? There’s little risk to asking for more and the very real potential to let millions of dollars slip through your fingers. Remember that negotiation’s simply a conversation whose goal is to reach an agreement that is satisfactory to both parties. You’re not haggling over the price of a rug. You’re engaging your new or potential boss in a bit of career planning. Employers like that. It makes you seem professional and sophisticated. That’s the kind of person they want to hire and to promote.
You’ve already worked this hard. Don’t undermine yourself. As an old friend of mine used to say, “Let’s plan for success instead of failure.” I’ve never said it better myself.
TopicsTools & Skills , The Gender Gap , Negotiation , Salaries , Raise , Syndication , Negotiation & Money
Victoria Pynchon is an attorney who practiced commercial litigation for 25 years. Since 2004, she has been mediating and arbitrating commercial disputes—the former with ADR Services, Inc. in Century City and the latter with the American Arbitration Association in Los Angeles. In 2010, she founded She Negotiates Consulting and Training with her business partner Lisa Gates. In 2006, Victoria earned her legal masters degree in Dispute Resolution. She has been teaching negotiation and providing negotiation consulting services to lawyers, executives, professionals and entrepreneurs ever since. She is the author of two books, The Grownups' ABCs of Conflict Resolution (2010) and Success as a Mediator for Dummies (2012).More from this Author